Cold email follow-up templates: three emails to copy
Three follow-up emails with the gap between each, and how to run them in PlusVibe so they stop on reply. Pricing read on the vendor's page.
Affiliate link. I may earn a commission if you subscribe, at no extra cost to you. Disclosure.
Use three emails: the opener, a reply in the same thread four to nine days later, and a third email under a new subject line, never spaced exactly seven days from the one before. PlusVibe runs that sequence from $37 a month for 25,000 emails.
This site may earn a commission if you buy PlusVibe through its links, at no extra cost to you.
| Step | Gap from the previous email | Subject line | What the email does |
|---|---|---|---|
| Email 1 | day 0 | short, one test variant if you want one | trigger, offer, one question, no link |
| Follow-up 1 | 4 to 9 days, not 7 | empty, so it threads | one new argument, one proof, one call to action |
| Email 3 | 4 to 9 days, shifted a weekday | new subject | the offer again in two arguments, a numbered reply |
Copy the three emails
Square brackets are the variables to fill. Each email stays under a hundred words, and none of them says "just following up".
Email 1, subject "[Trigger] at [Company]": "Hi [First name], I saw [specific trigger]. We help [role] teams [result] without [usual cost]. Worth a short exchange this week, yes or no?"
Follow-up 1, subject empty: "Hi [First name], one detail I left out. [One argument the opener did not make.] [One proof: a client reference or a market figure.] Would it help if I sent two lines on how it would work for [Company]?"
Email 3, new subject "[Result] for [Company]": "Hi [First name], different angle. Two reasons teams like yours call us: [argument one] and [argument two]. Reply 1 if you are interested, 2 if it is interesting but not now, 3 if you would rather not hear from us again."
Why they read this way. In a December 2023 video, Louis describes the follow-up as an email that never makes the person feel guilty for not answering: a plain greeting, one argument, one reassurance element, a call to action. The third email is written like a new first contact, and the numbered reply gives people who say 3 a way out we can ask about, which feeds the next version of the copy.
Variant for a link: in the second email, write "Reply Go and I will send the short video". The link goes in the next message. In a January 2026 masterclass we kept links out of the opener on purpose, since the filters should see a plain message before they see a link.
Set the sequence in PlusVibe so it threads and stops
An empty subject keeps the email in the thread. Instantly's and lemlist's help centers both say a follow-up step with an empty subject, or one that inherits the previous subject, stays in the same thread, and that a different subject opens a new one. PlusVibe's own help article on Auto Follow-Up does not describe the subject field of a campaign step, so send the sequence to two of your own inboxes before the real list and check that the second email sits under the first.
Next, the gap. Each step waits a number of days after the previous email, not after day 0. A 4-day gap on step two and a 9-day gap on step three is two separate numbers, and the second one is counted from the second email.
Last, stopping. The PlusVibe article says an incoming reply from a lead stops that lead's auto follow-up sequence immediately, and that leads currently in a subsequence do not receive auto follow-ups. Instantly documents the same switch under "Stop sending emails on reply" and notes that turning it on later does not stop leads who already replied. Check your campaign for the equivalent setting before the first send, because a prospect who answered and then gets a third email is the failure that costs the most.
PlusVibe's Auto Follow-Up works on a different job: it sends nudges after an email you wrote from the Unibox, and it restarts from step 1 for each outgoing Unibox email. It does not stand in for the campaign sequence above.
PlusVibe's plans are priced by email volume and active leads, not by mailbox. The Personal plan is $37 a month with 25,000 emails and 30,000 active leads, and the pricing page shows $30.8 a month on its yearly toggle. A 14-day trial at $0 includes 1,000 emails, enough to run the sequence on a small list before paying. The catalogue entry carries the full plan list and the current offer.
Space the emails by days, not by calendar habit
The gap in our December 2023 video is four to nine days, and never exactly seven: seven days lands the next email on the same weekday, and a person who is away that day will miss both. There is no universal rule there, so test the days on your own list.
Smartlead's benchmark of more than 850 million emails found 93.9% of replies arrive within 72 hours of an email. Rework, reading several vendors' data, finds that tools disagree: Instantly suggests 3 to 4 days between touches, lemlist suggests at least 2 days between the first two emails, and no source it cites tests one gap against another.
Stop at three, then change the angle or the channel
Our default is three messages, no more and no fewer: the opener, the reply in the thread, then a new subject. The Smartlead data supports the length: the median sequence in its 850 million emails runs 3 emails, and the longest 25% run 4 or more. Rework cites other sources that stretch to seven, and Belkins is reported there as seeing volume fall sharply beyond step 5.
After the third email, move to LinkedIn. We run email in PlusVibe and LinkedIn in a separate tool, GetSales, as two single-channel tools. The LinkedIn outreach at scale guide covers the second half, and signals beat lists explains why a fresh event at the prospect is the only good reason to write again.
If you do add a fourth email, do not send it inside the thread: a new trigger deserves a new subject and a new opener.
Test the copy before the whole list gets it
Before sending at volume, run an inbox placement test on every new sequence with its new copy, under real sending conditions and without click tracking. Copy alone can move placement. PlusVibe's pricing page lists a separate placement test product, with a Starter plan at $19 a month for 300 credits a month, a Growth plan at $39 for 1,000 and a Scale plan at $89 for 5,000.
Each week we review every mailbox's seven-day rolling reply rate in PlusVibe, move the weakest into warm-up, and put them back only after a clean placement test. The infrastructure checks before you send come first; a follow-up template cannot rescue a mailbox that lands in spam.
What breaks
- A link in the opener breaks the order we use: in a January 2026 masterclass the first email carries no link, and the follow-up carries it once the opener has cleared the filters.
PlusVibe against Instantly: how PlusVibe compares with Instantly.
PlusVibe is an affiliate partner of this site: a link on this page earns a commission and gives you 15 percent off the first three months, an offer arranged with the vendor that its pricing page does not list.
Where these numbers come from
- PlusVibe pricing page read 17 Nov 2026
- PlusVibe help center, Auto Follow-Up read 17 Nov 2026
- Instantly help center, keep sequences in the same thread read 17 Nov 2026
- Instantly help center, follow-ups sent after a reply read 17 Nov 2026
- lemlist help center, follow-ups in the same thread read 17 Nov 2026
- Smartlead benchmark, sequence length (850 million emails) read 17 Nov 2026
- Rework, cold email follow-ups read 17 Nov 2026
- Louis Deslus on YouTube, December 2023 read 8 Dec 2023
- Louis Deslus on YouTube, December 2023 read 8 Dec 2023
- Louis Deslus on YouTube, December 2023 read 18 Dec 2023
- Louis Deslus on YouTube, December 2023 read 18 Dec 2023
- Louis Deslus on YouTube, January 2026 read 16 Jan 2026
- Louis Deslus on YouTube, February 2026 read 11 Feb 2026
- EraB2B call recording, November 2026 dated 13 Nov 2026
What people still ask
Should a cold email follow-up have its own subject line?
Not the second email. Leave the subject empty so it lands as a reply in the first thread. The third email is the exception: it carries a new subject line, because the first one may have sat under a subject that meant nothing to the reader.
Does PlusVibe's Auto Follow-Up replace a sequence?
No. Its help article describes follow-ups for emails you send from the Unibox, set by labels and a number of days. Leads enrolled in a subsequence do not receive them, and any reply from the lead stops them.
Can I put a link in a cold email follow-up?
Yes, but not in the opener. We hold the link back until the follow-up, after the opener has cleared the spam filters, or ask a yes or no question first and send the link after the answer.